Bishop Kenny Bulls Over Toros, As Crusaders Move To 3-0

St. Augustine Fl- The weather delayed several games on Friday night, including the one scheduled to start at 7pm between the Bishop Kenny Crusaders and the Tocoi Creek Toros. While other games in St. John’s County were canceled, this one was not, instead starting at 8pm.

Yet Tocoi Creek might’ve wanted the game to have been postponed, as Bishop Kenny ran them out of their own stadium. The Crusaders scored four touchdowns on the ground, and completely pounded the Toros defensive line into submission. scores by Jelani Dawkins and Derek Heideman in the second half, sealed the win. When it was all said and done, BK bulled over the Toros 35-6 to improve to 3-0 on the season.

Player of the Game:

That goes to sophomore Caleb Mattison who rushed for two touchdowns in the game. Mattison was given the ball early and often as he moved the pile for first downs. His hard running punished tacklers, and by the second half Tocoi Creek didn’t want to tackle him. This 54-yard scamper put the game out of reach right after halftime.

Punishing Hits:

Bishop Kenny’s defense laid the wood on Tocoi Creek. Every time a Toro ball carrier would seem to have day light, the alley would close with a thunderous knock to the sound of pads and helmets. They also pressured Tocoi when they were forced to pass the ball. James Davis III a 6’2, 205lbs edge rusher was one of the players in the back field all night long for Kenny. Gunnar Rogers and Aiden Piper plugged holes, preventing any momentum from Tocoi Creek.

Big Play Second Quarter:

Bishop Kenny set up their second score of the game by executing big plays in the passing game in the second quarter. Already leading 7-0, thanks to a Mattison touchdown run, quarterback Derek Heideman found JP Donovan for a long gain down the middle. Heideman would go back to his sure-handed receiver with just seconds remaining in the half as Heideman threw the fade to Donovan who came down with the score to put the Crusaders up 14-0 going into halftime.

Missing Piece:

Tocoi Creek is missing their top wide receiver Julio Santiago and it showed. Without someone to stretch the field, or make plays in space, Tocoi struggled to reach the end-zone. The Toros have been without him all season, but still managed to generate enough offense against First Coast and Westside high schools to win their first two games. Not the case against a fired up and physical Bishop Kenny squad who forced several punts and 3 and outs.

Outlook:

For Tocoi Creek, this seemed like the year they would finally get a win in the series as the teams have played several times the last few years. It would not be the case. They must regroup quickly because the hardest portion of their schedule begins after a bout against Clay next week.

Bishop Kenny has started the season very strong with two 40-point wins against Matanzas and Episcopal. They added a 30-point victory over Tocoi tonight in a dominating fashion. Now they turn their sights toward their annual match-up against Bolles next week.

About the author

Andre' Ellis, Founder/ Lead Writer DuvalSports.com Florida Times Union All-City 1998,LB, Sandalwood Florida A&M Unv, BA , MBA

Other Stories

Week 6 Power Rankings: Raines Walks The Walk, And Talks The Talk At Mid-Season Mark
September 25, 2026
Week 5 Volleyball Power Rankings: Wolfson’s On The Prowl, Baldwin’s On The Hunt, And Bishop Kenny Fights Back
September 23, 2026
Fleming Island vs Middleburg: A Battle for Ruler of Clay County at The Nest
September 23, 2026
Raines Blindsides And Bludgeons Mandarin 31-13 In The Graveyard
September 19, 2026
Week 5 Power Rankings: Fletcher Downs Another Unbeaten, While Mandarin And Raines Decide Who Remains Unbeaten
September 18, 2026
Week 4 Volleyball Top 10: Life’s A Beach As Beachside, Fletcher And Ponte Vedra Ride Waves To The Top
September 18, 2026
Duval Sports D1 Prospects: Week 4 Ridgeview Versus Fleming Island
September 17, 2026
St. Augustine Keeps On Surging, 4-0 Ahead Of Tough Orlando Evans Test
September 15, 2026
Kickoff Time: Browns Versus Jaguars Game and Fantasy Preview
September 13, 2026
Three Running Backs Score For Mandarin, In Rushing Relay Rout Of Nease
September 12, 2026

GET YOUR PLAYER PROFILE NOW!

Click The Picture To Get Your Player Profile!

Advertisement

Click Picture To Learn More!

Contact Us: Info@duvalsports.com